Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker vs Alternatives: Which Is Best?Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker (EIPB) is a specialized tool designed to recover — or more precisely, extract — stored web credentials from browsers and password managers on Windows systems. It’s marketed primarily to forensic investigators, IT administrators, and security professionals who need to access credentials from a target machine during incident response, computer forensics, or lawful investigations. This article compares EIPB to popular alternatives, outlines strengths and limitations, and helps you decide which tool best fits different use cases.
What Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker does
Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker focuses on retrieving web account credentials saved by browsers and some password managers. Key capabilities include:
- Extracting stored passwords from major browsers (Chrome, Chromium-based browsers, Firefox, Internet Explorer, Edge) when possible.
- Decrypting and exporting saved credentials from Windows user profiles.
- Accessing credentials stored in Internet Explorer/Edge Protected Storage and the Windows Credential Manager where applicable.
- Operating on live systems or offline images (forensic copies).
Primary use cases: forensic investigations, incident response, internal audits, recovering forgotten logins when legal and authorized.
Important legal and ethical note
Using tools to extract credentials can be lawful only with proper authorization (e.g., owner consent, lawful warrant, corporate policy). Unauthorized access to accounts or systems is illegal in most jurisdictions. This article assumes legitimate, authorized use.
Major alternatives
Below are several well-known alternatives that overlap with EIPB’s capabilities, with different emphases and feature sets:
- Passware Kit Forensic
- Elcomsoft Distributed Password Recovery (EDPR) — complementary Elcomsoft product focused on brute force / GPU-accelerated password recovery
- NirSoft utilities (e.g., WebBrowserPassView, CredentialsFileView)
- Mimikatz (credential extraction, Windows memory and LSASS targeting)
- Belkasoft Evidence Center / Belkasoft WebBrowserPasswords module
- Oxygen Forensic Detective (mobile & desktop forensic suite)
- Commercial password managers’ built-in export tools (for lawful access when credentials and master passwords are available)
Feature-by-feature comparison
| Feature / Tool | Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker | Passware Kit Forensic | NirSoft utilities | Mimikatz | Belkasoft Evidence Center |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Browser password extraction (Chrome/Edge/Firefox) | Yes | Yes | Yes (several tools) | Limited | Yes |
| Windows Credential Manager extraction | Yes | Yes | Varies | Yes | Yes |
| Works with offline images | Yes | Yes | No | Can be used against memory dumps | Yes |
| GPU-accelerated brute force | No (EIPB focuses on extraction) | Yes (with Passware components) | No | No | No |
| Memory/LSASS extraction | No | Optional/limited | No | Yes | Some capability |
| Forensic reporting & case management | Basic exports | Extensive | Minimal | Minimal | Extensive |
| Ease of use (GUI) | User-friendly | User-friendly | Simple CLI/GUI tools | Technical, CLI | User-friendly, comprehensive |
| Price / Licensing | Commercial | Commercial | Mostly free | Free (but risky/legal) | Commercial |
Strengths of Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker
- Focused, straightforward interface for extracting browser and Windows-stored credentials.
- Solid compatibility with mainstream browsers and Windows versions.
- Can operate on live systems and offline forensic images.
- Designed for forensic workflows — exports in formats useful for analysis.
- Manufacturer (Elcomsoft) has long-standing reputation in forensic and password-recovery tools.
Limitations of Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker
- Not designed for brute-force cracking of master passwords or encrypted archives — that is covered by other Elcomsoft products (e.g., Distributed Password Recovery).
- Lacks deep memory/LSASS dumping capabilities; tools like Mimikatz are used for that.
- Commercial licensing and cost may be prohibitive compared with free tools for some users.
- Effectiveness can be limited if credentials are protected by additional layers (e.g., device-bound encryption, strong master passwords, or hardware-backed key storage).
When to choose Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker
Choose EIPB when:
- You need a focused, reliable way to extract saved web credentials from Windows machines and forensic images.
- You prefer a GUI tool tailored for forensic investigators and want exportable evidence formats.
- You require vendor support and a maintained commercial product with regular updates for new browser versions.
Examples:
- Lawful forensic analysis of a suspect’s PC where browser-stored logins are relevant.
- Corporate incident response to quickly inventory exposed web account credentials on a compromised machine.
When an alternative is better
- Need to recover encrypted archives or brute-force master passwords: use Elcomsoft Distributed Password Recovery or Passware Kit with GPU acceleration.
- Need to extract credentials from live memory or obtain clear-text passwords from LSASS: use Mimikatz (with legal caution) or a forensic suite that includes memory analysis.
- Budget constraints or simple cases: NirSoft utilities can extract browser-stored passwords quickly for local, authorized use.
- You require an end-to-end forensic platform (case management, timeline, wide artifact support): consider Belkasoft or Oxygen Forensic.
Practical considerations for forensic and admin workflows
- Evidence preservation: always image drives and document chain-of-custody before running extraction tools when working in a forensic context.
- Encryption and hardware keys: modern browsers may tie saved credentials to OS-level or hardware keys (TPM, Windows Hello). Some credentials may be unrecoverable without the user’s login credentials or system keys.
- Live vs offline analysis: live extraction can recover credentials stored in volatile memory; offline image analysis avoids altering the original system but may miss keys available only when the system is live.
- Combine tools: real investigations often use multiple tools — EIPB for browser stores, EDPR for cracking protected archives, Mimikatz for live memory credential grabs, and full-suite forensic platforms for reporting.
Example workflow (for a lawful forensic case)
- Create a forensically sound disk image of the target system.
- Mount image read-only in your analysis workstation.
- Run Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker against relevant user profiles to extract stored browser credentials.
- If master-password-protected vaults are encountered, export the vaults and use a GPU-accelerated cracker (EDPR or Passware) if you have authorization.
- If necessary and permitted, perform a live memory capture and analyze with Mimikatz for additional credentials.
- Document findings and export reports in standardized formats for court or internal records.
Security, legality, and ethics recap
- Always obtain legal authorization. Unauthorized credential extraction is illegal.
- Prefer documented corporate policies, warrants, or owner consent.
- Maintain chain-of-custody and forensic best practices to ensure evidence admissibility.
Conclusion
Elcomsoft Internet Password Breaker is a strong, specialized choice when your primary need is extracting stored web credentials from Windows systems and forensic images. It’s user-friendly, maintained, and fits neatly into forensic workflows. If you need brute-force cracking, memory/LSASS extraction, or a full forensic platform with extensive reporting, combine EIPB with complementary tools (EDPR, Mimikatz, Passware, Belkasoft) or choose a different suite depending on priorities like cost, depth of analysis, and GPU-accelerated recovery. The “best” tool depends on your exact requirements: targeted browser credential extraction (EIPB), password cracking (EDPR/Passware), memory credential harvesting (Mimikatz), or full-case management (Belkasoft/Oxygen).
Leave a Reply